Bryant Frazer of Studio Daily
stuck around for a great interview from Deluxe VP of Editorial Services Jay Tilin and colorist Martin Zeichner about using HDR
Deluxe Talks Dolby Vision, Daredevil and the Ins and Outs of HDR
Editorial Services VP Jay Tilin & Colorist Martin Zeichner on Doing Research, Making Metadata, and Setting DPs at Ease
Earlier this fall, Netflix summoned an array of technology journalists to New York to teach them about high dynamic range (HDR) technology, using the OTT
operator's range of Marvel superhero shows as a guide. The still-forthcoming Iron Fist
is Netflix's first Dolby Vision original show — that is, cinematographer Manuel Billeter is conceiving it for HDR from square one, rather than having it regraded after the SDR version has already been completed. But the case study for post-production was Daredevil
, which was regraded for HDR by colorist Tony D'Amore at Deluxe's L.A. facility. With reporters assembled in a grading suite at Deluxe in New York, D'Amore called in via telephone and oversaw a remote-grading session, controlling the New York office's Da Vinci Resolve software from the other coast and explaining the Dolby Vision process.
(Deluxe's claim to HDR fame?
The company has worked on more than 100 HDR titles — including, in its New York office, season 2 of Netflix's Marco Polo,
which it says was the first-ever Dolby Vision show.)
D'Amore described Dolby's crucial "content mapping" software, which analyzes the image to create metadata that will allow the image to appear correctly on playback, with brightness levels re-mapped to match the specific capabilities of any Dolby Vision-equipped display. The standard display used by Deluxe for HDR grading is the Dolby Pulsar monitor, which is a 4,000-nit display that far outstrips consumer monitor capabilities. (One nit = 1 candela per square meter.) Even so, it doesn't come close to maxing out the HDR spec, which supports up to 10,000 nits. For comparison's sake, Deluxe colorist Martin Zeichner said the Rec. 709 spec allows for 100 nits of peak brightness, while laser projectors in a theatrical setting can reach up to about 1,600 nits. The trick is generating metadata that will allow the image to be generated correctly under a range of varying viewing conditions.
for the future — just in case somebody does one day have a 4,000 nit TV, we're grading all the way up to it," D'Amore noted. "Even if you have a 600 nit TV, the mapping pushes the limits of the set you're watching on…. For the most part, anything above 500 nits is going to be really impressive."
How bright is too bright? Spectacular highlights on the Pulsar monitor were sometimes quite literally dazzling, making it difficult to focus on the very bright screen in the dark room. In response to a question from StudioDaily about the possible emergence of best practices for limiting brightness levels, D'Amore said HDR simply takes some getting used to. "Every DP
I've worked with so far on any of these shows I've done in HDR has said the same thing," he admitted. "The usual first reaction is, 'I don't like it. It's too bright. It's blinding me.' But what you notice is, the more you watch it, your eyes adjust to it…. It makes it true to life."
StudioDaily stuck around after the demo for an extended conversation with Zeichner and Jay Tilin, VP of Editorial Services for Deluxe and Company 3 in New York, about Deluxe's experiences implementing its HDR workflow. An edited transcript follows.
Colorist Martin Zeichner sits at the control panel at Deluxe's New York facility.
to read the edited transcript